- A new analysis concluded that ultraprocessed foods (UPFs) could be just as habit-forming as tobacco products.
- The study authors discovered that UPFs are engineered to boost pleasure and speed up the absorption of reinforcing ingredients.
- The habit-forming nature of these foods implies they promote compulsive consumption and interfere with appetite regulation.
- The researchers suggest that UPFs should be governed by regulations comparable to those for cigarettes.
At present, there is no one agreed-upon description of ultraprocessed foods. Some people define them as foods that include components you would not find in a home kitchen, such as stabilizers and additives.
Numerous experts employ the NOVA food categorization to define UPFs. This talks about foods that contain “formulations of ingredients, primarily of manufacturing origin, often made by a range of industrial techniques and processes.”
A recent paper featured in The Millbank Quarterly suggested that UPFs are potentially as addictive as tobacco products.
“It is my view with this research, as UPFs are deliberately designed to be incredibly tempting to the majority of people,” stated a bariatric surgeon not affiliated with the research.
Data from 2023 suggests that more than 73% of the foods available in the United States are ultraprocessed.
“Cigarettes and UPFs are not just natural products but carefully designed consumable products engineered deliberately to increase biological and psychological reward and compulsive consumption,” wrote the new study’s authors.
Can UPFs Habit-Forming?
This analysis combined insights from addiction, historical health policy, and dietary science to identify textural and compositional qualities that enhance the reinforcing potential of both cigarettes and UPFs.
“It’s not all people is ‘hooked’ to such products, but for a significant portion, they cause typical addiction-like behaviors: strong cravings, loss of control, and persistent consumption despite harmful consequences,” explained a heart health nutrition expert.
“These foods are intentionally designed with processed carbohydrates, extra oils, salt, and flavor enhancers to optimize reward and ongoing intake, and the industry uses persuasive advertising strategies, especially aimed at children,” she continued.
The authors focused on several important factors:
- delivery speed
- pleasure-based design, or creating products to be extremely pleasurable
- perfecting the amount
- environmental ubiquity
- misleading changes, or “health washing”
The study concluded that, like tobacco, ultraprocessed foods are fine-tuned to provide the optimal amount of sweetness.
“Processed carbs stimulate the feel-good chemical production through the vagus nerve, while lipids achieve this through intestinal lipid sensing,” the authors noted.
“… Ultraprocessed foods with significant amounts of refined carbohydrates and added fats are some of the most potently rewarding foods in the modern diet. Notably this refined carbohydrate-fat mix is rarely found in whole foods.”
The way these foods rapidly deliver “feel-good” substances to the brain renders them likely habit-forming, similarly to tobacco.
The paper explained that while tobacco are designed to provide nicotine rapidly, ultraprocessed foods are engineered to rapidly digest and absorb, as they usually have little to no dietary fiber. This allows for the body to process lipids and carbohydrates faster.
Authors also note that ultraprocessed foods give intentional intense tastes that dissipate rapidly and mouthfeels that melt in your mouth. This collectively works to trigger more dopamine and prompts you to eat more.
‘Wellness Branding’ in Tobacco, UPFs
According to the analysis, both the cigarette and food industries have historically employed a tactic known as “health washing.”
This refers to when products are advertised and reformulated to generate an illusion of reduced harm while maintaining the core of their properties.
This tactic in the tobacco industry became popular in the 1950s with the introduction of filters on cigarettes.
They were sold as safety features that would trap harmful substances before they entered the lungs. Actually, these tips provide minimal significant protection.
However, people typically adapted by inhaling deeper or smoking more frequently, which offset any reduction in harmful intake.
The food industry has adopted a similar strategy. It uses packaging claims such as “low fat” or “no sugar added” to promote ultraprocessed foods.
However, these foods often retain the very highly reinforcing ingredient combinations. The issue is that these reformulations present a surface-level impression of wellness while the product’s habit-forming nature and health risks persist unchanged.
Ought UPFs Be Regulated?
The authors stated at the end of their review that nourishment and tobacco are not the same thing.
Still, they warned that some ultraprocessed foods act like highly optimized products rather than actual food. They recommended that health regulations should reflect this reality.
“Tobacco provides a cautionary tale, and smoking regulations provides a model of hope,” the researchers wrote.
Due to policies, cigarette use levels in the United States have fallen and have “reshaped cultural views of smoking and diminished confidence in the industry.”
“I believe increased education regarding the harmful effects of UPFs is crucial to reduce public intake and enhance public health. The approaches used to curb cigarette consumption have been effective and may be a helpful blueprint for ultra-processed foods as well,” commented one expert.
“It is not my view UPFs should be regulated precisely like cigarettes, but they do warrant more robust, smoking policy-based policies: marketing restrictions, obvious packaging warnings, tighter rules on health claims, and limits in educational institutions or hospitals,” added another nutrition professional.
The authors pointed out to people that lightly altered and unprocessed foods have supported human health for millennia.